Should You Talk to Insurance After a West Hills Car Accident?
Your phone is ringing. An insurance adjuster wants to discuss your West Hills car accident. Maybe it happened on the 101 during your commute. Maybe at the intersection of Fallbrook Ave and Victory Blvd. Wherever it was, the adjuster sounds friendly and says they just want to "get your side of the story" so they can process the claim. Should you talk to them?
The answer depends on which insurance company is calling, and what you say.
Your Own Insurer vs. the Other Driver's Insurer
This distinction is everything. Most people do not realize they are dealing with two completely different situations when they hear from insurance after a crash.
Your own insurance company: You have contractual obligations to your insurer. Your auto policy requires you to cooperate with their investigation, report the accident promptly, and provide information about what happened. You generally need to communicate with your own insurer, and failing to do so can jeopardize your coverage.
That said, cooperation does not mean you have to accept blame, speculate about fault, or agree to anything without understanding what you are agreeing to. Be factual. Stick to what you know. Do not guess, estimate, or volunteer information beyond what is asked.
The other driver's insurance company: You have zero obligation to talk to them. None. They are not your insurer. You have no contract with them. They represent the person who may be responsible for your injuries, and their goal is to pay you as little as possible. Every word you say to the other driver's adjuster will be evaluated for ways to reduce your claim.
If the other driver's insurer calls, you have every right to say: "I am not going to discuss this with you. Please direct all communication to my attorney." If you do not have an attorney yet, you can simply say: "I am not prepared to give a statement at this time." You do not owe them an explanation.
The Recorded Statement Trap
The other driver's adjuster will almost certainly ask for a recorded statement. They will frame it as standard procedure, just a formality, nothing to worry about. It is not a formality. It is an evidence-gathering tool designed to benefit their side.
Here is what happens in a recorded statement: the adjuster asks you questions about the accident, your injuries, your medical history, and your daily activities. Your answers are recorded and transcribed. That transcript becomes part of the claim file and can be used against you in negotiations or at trial.
Common traps in recorded statements:
"How are you feeling today?" If you say "fine" or "okay" because that is what people say in conversation, the insurer will later argue you told them you were not significantly injured.
"Have you ever had back problems before?" Any acknowledgment of prior issues, even something minor from years ago, gets used to argue your current injuries are pre-existing.
"Can you describe exactly what happened?" If your description differs even slightly from the LAPD or CHP report, the insurer will highlight the inconsistency to undermine your credibility.
"Were you on your phone at the time?" Leading questions designed to establish comparative fault, even when no evidence supports it.
You are not required to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer. A West Hills car accident attorney will handle this communication for you and ensure nothing you say is used to undermine your claim.
What the Adjuster Actually Wants
Insurance adjusters are professionals. They handle hundreds of claims from the West San Fernando Valley every year. The adjuster calling you about your crash on Platt Ave or the 101 has seen cases like yours before and knows exactly what information helps them reduce your payout.
They want three things:
Admissions. Any statement that suggests you contributed to the crash or that your injuries are not serious. "I probably should have been paying more attention" becomes evidence of comparative fault. "It's not that bad" becomes evidence your injuries are minor.
Inconsistencies. Anything you say that conflicts with the police report, your medical records, or later statements. Inconsistencies, even minor ones caused by stress or imperfect memory, are used to question your credibility.
A quick settlement. The adjuster may offer you money fast, before you know the full extent of your injuries, before you have finished treatment, and before you know what your claim is actually worth. Early settlements are almost always below fair value. Once you accept and sign a release, you cannot go back for more.
What You Should Actually Say at the Scene
There is a difference between talking to insurance and talking to people at the accident scene. At the scene, you should:
Exchange insurance information and contact details with the other driver. This is required by California law.
Cooperate with the responding LAPD officer or CHP trooper. Give them your account of what happened. The police report is important evidence, and your statement to the officer shapes that report.
Do not admit fault. Do not say "I'm sorry" or "I didn't see you." Stick to facts: what you saw, what happened, where the vehicles were.
Talk to witnesses if possible. Get their names and phone numbers. Witness accounts can be the strongest evidence in your case.
When to Talk and When to Stop
Here is a simple framework:
Talk to: Your own insurer (factually, without speculation). The responding LAPD officer or CHP trooper. Your doctor. Your attorney.
Do not talk to: The other driver's insurer, at least not without your attorney present or handling it for you. The other driver's attorney, if one contacts you directly. Anyone posting about the accident on social media.
Social media deserves its own warning. Insurers routinely monitor claimants' social media accounts. A post about a weekend hike, a vacation photo, or even a check-in at Shadow Ranch Park can be used to argue that your injuries are not limiting your activities the way you claim. The safest approach during an active claim is to avoid posting about your physical activities entirely.
The Adjuster Called Before You Got a Lawyer
This happens frequently. The other driver's insurer calls within days, sometimes within hours, of the crash. They are hoping to get your statement before you have had time to assess your injuries, consult an attorney, or understand the value of your claim.
If you already spoke to the other driver's adjuster before reading this, do not panic. What you said is not necessarily fatal to your case. But it is a reason to get an attorney involved now, before any further communication occurs. Your attorney can manage the relationship going forward and address anything problematic in your earlier statements.
If the adjuster has not called yet, or if they called and you have not returned the call, talk to an attorney first. The consultation is free, and the attorney can advise you on exactly what to say and what not to say moving forward.
Let Someone Handle This for You
Dealing with insurance adjusters while you are also dealing with injuries, medical appointments, and the stress of a car accident is exhausting. One of the most practical benefits of hiring an attorney is that they take over all communication with insurers. You stop fielding calls. You stop worrying about saying the wrong thing. You focus on recovering.
Contact our West Hills personal injury attorneys for a free consultation. We handle the insurance companies so you do not have to.
Injured in West Hills? Talk to a local attorney, no fee unless we win.
Learn about our West Hills personal injury services →
Talk to a senior attorney directly.
